What is territorial aggression and how can it be diagnosed?
Territorial or protective aggression may be exhibited toward people or other animals that approach the pet’s property. Generally people and other animals that are unusual, less familiar to the dog, or most unlike the members of the household are the most likely “targets” of territorial aggression. In other words something about the sight, sound or actions of the stimulus is causing an alerting, anxious or defensive response on the part of the dog. While most forms of territorial aggression are likely to occur on the property, some dogs may protect areas where they are temporarily housed and may protect family members regardless of the location. Territorial aggressive displays may vary, ranging from growling and barking to lunging, chasing, snapping and biting. Territorial displays may occur at windows, doors, behind fences and in the car. Some dogs may quickly claim territory and show similar behaviors at picnic areas, park benches, etc. Dogs that are physically prevented by a barricade or leash from gaining access to the stimulus (frustration) may have their aggression heightened or may develop displacement behaviors (e.g. spinning, circling, self mutilation) or redirected behaviors (e.g. turning their aggression on the owner who attempts to reach for or grab the dog. Many dogs continue their aggression once the person has entered the territory or home, which could result in biting and severe injury. In some cases due to the high arousal level of the dog, an element of frustration may also be present and can lead to redirected behavior toward objects or other animals or people.
How can territorial aggression be prevented?
Territorial aggression can be prevented or minimized with early socialization and good control. Young dogs should be taught to sit and receive a reward as each new person comes to the door. To reduce potential fear and anxiety toward visitors, you should ensure that a wide variety of visitors come over to visit the puppy while the puppy is young and sociable (see our handout on ‘Socializing your new puppy’). In time, most dogs will begin to alert the family by barking when strangers come to the home. However the dog that has been well socialized and under good control can be trained to quickly settle down and relax.
Why are territorial behaviors ongoing and perhaps even increasing?
For many dogs territorial displays are a normal part of their behavioral repertoire. While any dog may show territorial responses, certain breeds of dogs have been bred for guarding and watchful behaviors. Without appropriate supervision, owner interaction and training of appropriate responses these dogs may engage in territorial displays that vary in intensity from mild barking to intense displays that might include growling, snarling, lunging, piloerection and even biting a person or animal entering the territory. Opportunity and environmental access to the stimulus will influence whether the behavior will take place. Without proper owner supervision and training, these behaviors may become excessive. Dogs that are tied may show extreme territorial behaviors and aggressive responses. Dogs that are left outside all day without owner supervision are also at risk for escalating territorial responses. Many dogs that show territorial responses are often fearful and anxious and just want the intruder to leave.
The longer the person stays within the territory, the more aggressively aroused the dog may become. The goal of the territorial display is to get the “intruder” to leave. The longer the stimulus remains in place within sight or hearing of the pet, while the pet is frustrated from chasing the stimulus away because it is tied, penned or behind closed windows or doors, the greater the anxiety. Although dogs with mild fears might habituate with continued exposure, dogs that are constantly exposed (flooded) by an anxiety-evoking stimulus will have their fear heightened until the stimulus leaves. The removal (retreat) of the individual then further reinforces the strength of the response.
How can I treat territorial aggression?
For dogs exhibiting territorial aggression, you will need to gain enough control to have your dog sit, stay and when calmed down, take a reward at the front door. Generally a leash and head collar will give the fastest and most effective control. Teaching the dog to settle on command near the vicinity of the front door is an essential first step (See handout on settling your dog). If the dog cannot do that, then they should be removed from the area prior to admitting people into the home. Providing safety for individuals who must come to the home is essential. If the dog is showing territorial aggressive responses to visitors it should be removed and securely confined when company is present to avoid injury. If redirected behavior is a component of the initial problem it may be necessary to separate dogs to prevent fighting and injury if the problem dog encounters the stimulus. Owners should not reach for the dog when he is aggressively aroused to avoid injuries to them. If barking precedes the aggression you might be able to stop the sequence of events and train the dog to settle with products that inhibit barking such as the bark activated citronella collar or a hand held alarm (see below). However, you must be present to immediately reinforce the quiet and settled behavior with a favored treat or reward.
Another essential first step is to no longer allow territorial aggressive displays to continue. An effort should be made to prevent ongoing territorial displays either at windows or along fence lines. This might mean blocking visual access out windows by covering them up or preventing the dog from getting to them, and not allowing outdoor access unless the dog is wearing a leash and head collar and is actively supervised by an adult who is holding onto the dog’s leash. Punishment must be stopped since punishment tends to increase rather than decrease the anxiety and fear that may be underlying the behavior.
Once your dog can settle on command, more detailed training can occur. All the stimuli that provoke the territorial response should be identified and a response gradient determined; i.e. at what distance is the territorial response noted and how does the response vary with changing distance (approaching and retreating)? Using a desensitization and counter-conditioning program (See our handout on counter-conditioning and desensitization) you can begin retraining with low levels of stimuli (such as people arriving in a car, walking past the front of the house, or perhaps even a family member knocking on the door or ringing the bell). The idea is that each time someone arrives at the house or rings the bell, the dog will come to expect a favored reward (toy, cheese, hot dog slice or play session). Once the dog can be controlled and receives rewards in this environment, gradually more intense stimuli can be used.
A big part of my dog’s problem is barking. How can I control that?
Some dogs confine their territorial display to barking and nothing else. Teaching the dog to reliably respond to a command that signals quiet is essential. In some cases an anti-bark collar, bark activated alarm or a shaker can or audible device that is activated by the owner will disrupt the barking (at least temporarily). In this interval where the dog is quiet you must reinforce the quiet behavior with a favored treat or toy. Over time gradually increase the quiet time before the reward is given and provide multiple rewards if the dog does not bark at all. With some other dogs it may be more difficult to control barking, so please see our handouts on barking and management devices for additional treatment methods.